www.designtimeline.org defining a decade of web design

[ Timeline: Zoom Out ] [ Questions ] [ About this Site ] preferred language:

Q: Should you use frames? — Editor / 30 Answers

[ answer this question ] [ translate this question ]

1996

4 Answers

A: there are no rules, use whatever you need — harm [add comment]

A: Of course www.teleporta... — agatha [2 comments]


A: Obey Jakob www.tommcmaho... — Femke Snelting [add comment]

A: Web usability guru Jakob Nielsen is in 1996 van mening dat "Frames Suck (Most of the Time)". Hij is er zo op tegen omdat het gebruik van Frames volgens hem het basisprincipe van het web (de pagina) tenietdoet. www.useit.com... — Femke Snelting [add comment]

1997

2 Answers

A: no - but I have in the past — traceyb [add comment]

A: Why any one would I'd never know! Personally Iused them, once, a long time ago around 1997 or so but never since and probably never again.! — s2art [add comment]

2000

3 Answers

A: Frames erleichtern es den privaten Homepage-Autoren einfach schnell und leicht ein Grundlayout zu bauen und ebenfalls einfach die Inhalte einzubauen bzw. aktuell zu halten. Ich verwende immer noch Frames. Der Vorteil von Frames sind, dass sich oft nur der Inhalt ändert und nicht jede Seite komplett neu geladen wird. Alternativ kann man aúch entsprechende HTML-Editoren oder andere Webprogrammiersprachen wie PHP verwenden, die mit anderen Techniken framelose Webseiten erzwingen. Dies ist zwar anwenderfreundlicher, jedoch wird durch framelose Techniken, die Ladezeit einzelner Webseiten erhöht. Frames sind aus meiner Sicht immer nicht out ! de.geocities.... — jodigi [add comment]

A: I use frames since my first homepage relaunch. de.geocities.... — jodigi [add comment]

A: depends on application — Dominik Hruza [add comment]

2001

1 Answer


A: yes!!! when you need a simple, cross-platform (well, sorta) solution. www.collatera... — deb [add comment]

2003

4 Answers


A: Yes - frames rule. www.wellesley... — Jessica Irish [add comment]

A: no... btw, iframes are useful sometimes ;) www.desvirtua... — giselle beiguelman [add comment]

A: I don't use frames in a website that has a lot of content which can be deep-linked. I think deep-linking is useful, and frames do not allow it. — ripvanwinkle [add comment]


A: I still use frames. It's a good way to present separate file and or live feeds in a browser. nujus.net — G.H. Hovagimyan [add comment]

2004

14 Answers

A: No. They will screw your SEO and make your site inaccessible. — Marcos Drake [add comment]

A: noooooooooooooooooooooo :) i'm not really a big fan of frames, thinking of all the problems they can cause.. iframes however are pretty nifty things (but also cause problems now and then) a good table design does it for me.. — bruno [add comment]


A: Not unless it's necessary conceptually or technically. There's always the issues with bookmarking and people coming from search engines. But the main consideration is: 'do I create a set of content pages or a web application?' Content pages should be easily re-usable (copying text, printing, bookmarking,...); web applications should be fast and compact. — Maarten Handstede [add comment]

A: Yes, when you need to control what the viewer sees and how they see it. — Teresa Fogard [add comment]

A: NEVER !!!!! www.pixelmorp... — kirsten wolf [1 comment]

A: Absolutely! — Simon Heilesen [add comment]

A: I'm going to say no on this one. Frames are still cause access problems and arn't necessary. comp.uark.edu... — brescia [add comment]


A: I try not to -- I never do now that I have a good understanding of CSS and using PHP include files. The only reason to use frames is if you don't understand how to compartmentalize the different pieces by using code that runs on the server -- which actually turns out to be much easier and less confusing, once you get the hang of it. Here are some of my Demonstration scripts -- grab the code if you can use it. http://artdev.uga.edu artdev.uga.edu — jwilley [add comment]

A: and not only frames, but iframes as well. — agatha [add comment]

A: yes before, not now www.michelcle... — mc [add comment]

A: No, thank you. — Jennifer [add comment]

A: Frames are the solace of those who don't or won't understand information architecture. They make it hard for disabled users, make it hard to provide intelligent links to the content that people are actually interested in, and make something elegant inelegant. Work of the devil. 'Nuf said. — Adrian Miles [2 comments]


A: No, you can't bookmark pages, they don't work in text only browsers, and they are fairly inaccessible (much like Flash, unfortunately). www.bluemooni... — jgomula [add comment]

A: yes. lots of them. constantly — alex hetherington [add comment]

post-04

2 Answers

2005

2 Answers

A: No, not in this world www.paulapowe... — paula [add comment]

A: only if you really really have thought it through — Pam [add comment]

You are not logged in. Login